Question: Do you guys prefer comment windows that pop up, or comments listed on an archive page? As you know, my site uses the latter. It’d be pretty trivial to bring pop-ups back on the home page, though, if people want them. (The archive pages would still remain as they are.) Whaddaya think?

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPin on PinterestShare on Google+

15 Comments

Add yours →

  1. I think I prefer it the way it is now.

  2. Hmmmm. I think it depends on my mood. Most of the time, tho….I like the pop-up kind. It’s cool, either way. I’m adaptable :)

  3. no we hates popupsies. sssss.

  4. Mia – nice blog! I love the title. I want a WWBSD bracelet. :)

  5. I’m not a big fan of the pop-ups either. MT has them as a default, and I quickly got rid of them.

  6. Ahhh, see, all you MT folks were the reason I started second guessing myself!

  7. I used to prefer pop-ups, but I gotta say, I’m back to keeping them on my entry page again now *shrugs*

  8. I’m with Bill–I like going over to the archive page. Now I gotta learn how to get rid of the pop-ups on my site.

  9. I prefer the comments being on the archive page. Pop-up windows are a pain.

  10. The pop-up comments option requires javascript, and more than 10 percent of surfers have disabled javascript either by choice or because they’ve been required to do so (this is a growing trend in corporations where stressed IT support folks simply find life easier if java, javascript, and Flash are disabled). That’s why I don’t use them for comments. (I do, however, use them begrudgingly for thumbnail photos that pop up to full size when clicked because I have to create those manually, and the pop-up window is an easy Dreamweaver extension.)

  11. Thanks for the input, you guys, and for the great explanation, Ron. I prefer it this way too. I just wanted to check because I suddenly realized a lot of folks had them, and I’m all about being user-friendly.

  12. Thanks for the compliment about my blog, Kris….I must admit YOU are my inspiration. I just fear that it’s a little TOO neurotic for the masses.

  13. I like that popups enable you to stay on the blog page but prefer this way as the full blog can be displayed at the top. I suppose you could also have this style of page open a new window but then it would just cover the blog page anyway.

    I’ll just shut up.

  14. I’m a fan of that too, Jann. When I visit my own site I hold down the option key (yay, Mac!) when I click on the comment links, which opens them in a new window. I tend to have lots of windows open when I browse. :)

  15. Pop ups suck big time. Leave it as it is.

Comments are closed.